data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/31cbf/31cbf65cc7747943a09d71fb7b1a4098899b15ec" alt="Kanye west dark fantasy cover art"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/40415/404159ecf3dad6560dd9c987b9d1c2bfc010e1a7" alt="kanye west dark fantasy cover art kanye west dark fantasy cover art"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/33281/3328163ec0bdcdd14989b4a2f134950dd33afaad" alt="kanye west dark fantasy cover art kanye west dark fantasy cover art"
They’ve listened as Kanye gets his kicks from pretending to be the first hip-hop producer since perhaps the RZA who can claim to be a composer, a true studio producer who arranges and directs a song from skeletal idea to full-formed beast. And as they’ve listened, those who felt let down already continued to feel so as West sings his way through a good portion of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. In the week leading to this album’s leak, many Internet listeners arrived at disappointment through the revelation they’d heard most of the album - however disjointedly - over the previous months.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/947a1/947a14b653170cdf3cb96bd7b19d03222a143e69" alt="kanye west dark fantasy cover art kanye west dark fantasy cover art"
I’ve seen it happen already, and it’s not pretty. These are the lines along which a cluster of hip-hop geeks will undoubtedly entrench themselves, debating the merits of each in regards to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. 2! Kanye, you did me all the way wrong on that one! All the way! Friday, not album tracks!! Kanye isn’t a straight up MC anymore, where’s the College Dropout-era charm and humor I was promised? This is practically 808s & Heartbreaks, Pt. Half these songs were supposed to be G.O.O.D. “All of the Lights”‘ percussion is soooooo not hip-hop. Those verses from Raekwon, KiD CuDi, Rick Ross, and Fergie add nothing to the record. Those vocals on “Dark Fantasy”, layered a baker’s dozen different ways, they’re synthetic. I’ve got to take a moment to try and hate. Hey teacher teachers, how do we respond to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy? How do we respond to the most bloated, egotistical, fantastical, flat-out amazing release hip-hop has seen in three, five, ten years? Ever? I’m not sure what we’re supposed to do, so I’ve got to get the bogus stuff out of the way first.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d9a1b/d9a1baf6ad5fae04fff8eef7653ce786e78de733" alt="kanye west dark fantasy cover art kanye west dark fantasy cover art"
“Do you think I sacrificed real life for all the fame of flashing lights?” - Kanye West, “Pinnocchio Story”, 808s & Heartbreaks
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/31cbf/31cbf65cc7747943a09d71fb7b1a4098899b15ec" alt="Kanye west dark fantasy cover art"